Music & Drama Education Expo February 2023, London
On the 23rd of February 2023, I was delighted to represent the Music Education Council at the Music and Drama Expo at the Business Design Centre in London. I was chairing a panel discussion on Equity, Diversity and Inclusion (EDI) within the refreshed National Plan for Music Education (NPME) and MEC was there to put the spotlight on voices that are not usually heard in the sector. The panel included Sam Sikiru (Young Producer), Keith Sykes (Director of Community Music) and Tolu McCarthy (Music Educator).
The provocation discussed was: The national plan does not do enough to overhaul the way the sector views EDI. Urgent systemic change is needed to ensure that there is a unified understanding and sector-wide commitments to EDI.
Equity, diversity and inclusion within the National Plan
To begin the session we looked at the goals of the NPME:
1. All children and young people receive a high-quality music education in the early years and in schools
2. All music educators work in partnership, with children and young people’s needs and interests at their heart
3. All children and young people with musical interests and talents have the opportunity to progress, including professionally
Whilst ‘inclusion’ has many references, ‘equity’, ‘equality’ and ‘diversity’ don’t really feature within the plan.
It was clear from a word-analysis of the NPME that whilst ‘inclusion’ has many references, ‘equity’, ‘equality’ and ‘diversity’ don’t really feature within the plan.
Our panel members then went on to discuss this relating to their personal experiences.
Sam talked about growing up and studying the arts and he highlighted that under-represented groups can be included for the wrong reasons. It is important that all children and young people are included not just because the policy makers want them there, it’s not just a tick box exercise. Becoming aware that this is why you’ve been included can make you feel like your experience is invalidated. Sam made a plea to the policy makers to ensure that there is something in place whereby underrepresented groups of pupils don't feel like their experiences and achievements are not valid.
We then heard from Tolu who talked about her experience on a teacher training course. The course lecturer asked everybody what their musical backgrounds were and when Tolu spoke about singing in church and playing the keyboard the lecturer looked at her and asked, “Oh, so do you read sheet music?”. This is a valid question for a music course but it was interesting that he didn't ask anybody else, highlighting the need for systemic changes to attitudes within the sector. Tolu went on to explain that it's often down to the individual attitude of whoever is delivering your music education and you can have diversity plastered all over the NPME, but if the person delivering music education doesn't see the importance of EDI, it might not have much effect.
The discussion continued with a focus on the curriculum. Sam stated that music is very important to a lot of children and young people. It’s relied upon and is something that is used every single day, but a lot of music teachers kill the passion for music. Five lessons in a row going through Beethoven's music without exploring other genres isn’t going to have a big impact, whereas exploring different genres would be more relevant and engaging.
You can have diversity plastered all over the NPME but if the person delivering music education doesn’t see the importance, it might not have much effect.
Tolu then joined the conversation stating that it’s about balance and no one is saying do away with the Classical, Baroque, Romantic music, but there does need to be room for more modern genres to invite more children and young people to take a place at the table, and not feel isolated and ostracised because they don't know a certain symphony. Tolu’s plea was to simply have a more holistic approach to music.
Youth voice and co-production
We then heard from Keith who felt that the biggest missing area in the NPME was around youth voice. There was no mention of co-production with young people and it felt like a missed opportunity, because this is so central to equity, diversity and inclusion. Keith then went on to highlight some gaps - for example young carers aren’t included - and highlighted the need for equity of access for all young people to be more explicit. He believed that more detail was needed in the NPME to support this.
The IDEA Framework
The panel then went on to look at the IDEA framework (IDEA stands for Inclusion, Diversity, Equity and Access) and the IDEA project is facilitated by Youth Music and includes 8 Music Hubs (including Lewisham and Leicestershire) as part of the project.
The aim of the IDEA project is to pilot a brand-new accreditation framework and this is currently being tested through a year of action research, learning, and peer support.
IDEA is broken down into eight ‘pillars’ of practice:
Keith described how Lewisham Music has engaged with the project and how it has reinforced the policies that sat behind their work. Every Music Hub is on a different journey but this project has enabled them to focus on their individual journey and contribute to the national picture for EDI.
Calls to Action
The panel then shared their calls to action:
Speak to another teacher /Music Hub / school leader about EDI
When you are working with your young people, make a meaningful space for them – it’s not just a tick-box exercise
Take a risk –listen to your young people
Policy makers – look at your policies. Are they including underrepresented groups for the RIGHT reasons?
EDI is everyone's responsibility. Make ONE commitment to yourself and hold yourself accountable
Follow the underrepresented voices on your socials, engage with them, champion them and challenge those who go against this
Find out more about IDEA at www.youthmusic.org.uk/IDEA
After the session, the panel was approached by numerous people who attended the packed-out session in the Keynote Theatre. There were many messages of support and thanks for highlighting such an important issue. We were also asked what would be appearing next? Watch this space…!
Sharon Jagdev Powell MEC trustee and Interim Head of Leicestershire Music